Meta Advantage+: when it works and when more control is better

What Meta Advantage+ automates, which accounts it works best for, when it makes sense to turn off some of the automation, and how to give it good signals.

By Samuel Rodríguez, former Google paid media consultant

Cover of the guide to Meta Advantage+


Meta has been pushing automation for some time now. Today, when you create a sales campaign, Advantage+ is enabled by default: Meta decides who to show the ads to, in which placements, how to distribute the budget and, if you allow it, how to modify the creatives.

Today, what needs to be decided is which parts of the automation to leave on and which ones you should control yourself.

What Advantage+ automates

  • Audience. You can provide suggestions, but Meta can go further if it believes it will find conversions.

  • Placements. Facebook, Instagram, Messenger and Audience Network, distributing budget according to performance.

  • Budget. Distributed across ad sets and ads based on what works best.

  • Creatives. Automatic enhancements such as cropping, image adjustments, music, text variations or templates featuring catalogue products.

Each of these components can be turned on or off separately.

When it works well

  • There is conversion volume. Meta needs data to learn. As a benchmark, to exit the learning phase it needs around 50 conversions per week in each ad set. With fewer, automation is flying blind.

  • Measurement is reliable. Pixel and Conversions API properly configured, with no duplicate events and including the value of each purchase. If Meta receives bad data, it optimises towards the wrong thing.

  • The market is broad. Consumer products with a large potential audience, where the challenge is finding who is interested rather than deciding who to exclude.

  • You have creative variety. Targeting is now done by the creative. Multiple angles, formats and messages give Meta the material to find different audiences.

INITIAL AUDIT

Not sure if Advantage+ is right for your account?

We review your Meta campaigns and tell you how much control you should maintain.

When it is better to take more control

  • Low conversions or high average order value. If you close five sales a month, the algorithm has nothing to learn from. It is better to optimise towards an earlier funnel event or narrow the audience further.

  • B2B leads or highly qualified leads. Advantage+ optimises for volume. If cheap leads are poor quality leads, you need to feed quality back to Meta—for example, by sending qualified leads from your CRM—or maintain tighter audience control.

  • High proportion of existing customers. Without caps, part of the budget will go to people who were already going to buy. Define your existing customers in the account and review how much spend is allocated to that group.

  • Brand or legal restrictions. Sectors where you cannot allow Meta to change copy or images, or where certain placements are inappropriate. In these cases, it is best to disable automatic creative enhancements and review placements.

  • New accounts without history. Without historical data, starting with a more restricted structure helps you see what works before opening things up.

How to provide strong signals

  1. Check Events Manager: duplicate events, mismatched values and Event Quality Match scores.

  2. Send the real value of each purchase and, if possible, a margin-adjusted value.

  3. If you work with leads, upload to Meta which leads eventually became customers.

  4. Prepare three or four distinct creative angles per campaign. Three versions of the same ad count as just one angle.

  5. Review automatic creative enhancements one by one before publishing. Some add value, while others can leave your ad looking unintended.

INITIAL AUDIT

Would you like us to review your Meta campaigns?

In 20 minutes we examine signals, creatives and structure, and tell you what we would change first.

How we approach it

In most e-commerce accounts, we leave the audience and placements to Meta, manage the creatives ourselves, and separately track how much spend goes to new customers. In highly filtered lead accounts, we retain more control until the quality signal is properly set up.

If you would like us to review your account, here is how we approach Meta Ads management.